Most Florida flooding shows up like an uninvited houseguest: loud, sudden, and gone by morning. The St. Johns River is different. It's the houseguest who arrives slowly, unpacks, and asks how long you're planning to keep the guest room free.
That's what Seminole County has been preparing for this month. If you own a rental in Sanford, Geneva or anywhere near Lake Monroe, Lake Jesup or Lake Harney, this is a good weekend to run through a checklist. I've owned and managed Florida rentals for almost two decades, and Bartomeo Property Management manages hundreds of homes for owners, including in Seminole County. Here's how I'd handle a slow-moving flood as a landlord.
What Seminole County officials said to expect
WKMG News 6 reported on November 9 (updated November 10) that Seminole County Emergency Management was bracing for a prolonged flooding event as water from the earlier Brevard County storm moves north along the St. Johns River. According to that report:
- Lake Monroe could crest at more than 6 feet and Lake Harney at more than 10 feet.
- Steven Lerner, division manager for Seminole County Emergency Management, said cresting near Sanford and Lake Harney could come "as far out as the 20th of November all the way through the 23rd," calling it "a very prolonged slow flooding event."
- Officials said it could be well into December before water levels begin to recede, and more rain could push levels higher.
- Sandbag sites were set up at the Old Geneva Fire Station and Wayside Park near Lake Monroe, up to 15 bags per household.
Update, November 21: The outlook got worse after the latest heavy rain. WFTV reported on November 20 that Lake Monroe at Sanford was at 6.7 feet, in minor flood stage with parks and docks flooded, and was forecast to crest at 8 feet Tuesday afternoon. That's major flood stage, though still below the lake's 9-foot record. Lake Harney was forecast to reach 13 feet Sunday afternoon, above its previous record of 12.7 feet. The National Weather Service gauge for the St. Johns River near Sanford read 6.8 feet late on November 20, with a forecast peak of 8 feet. If you own near the water, this checklist just moved from "this weekend" to "today."
Forecasts change, and river forecasts especially. Before you act, check the current outlook from Seminole County Emergency Management and the National Weather Service. Don't run a rental on an old news article, including this blog post.
Step one: know which of your rentals are actually at risk
Not every Sanford rental is near the water, and not every lakeside street floods. Make a short list:
- Which homes are close to Lake Monroe, Lake Jesup, Lake Harney or the river, or in low spots that have held water before?
- What flood zone is each one in? Your insurance declarations or a flood zone lookup will tell you.
- Which ones have a garage, shed, pool equipment, AC condenser or water heater sitting low?
If the answer for a property is "nowhere near it," great. Cross it off and focus your attention where it matters.
Step two: talk to your tenants early, calmly and in writing
Your tenants live there. They'll probably notice rising water before you do, and they deserve to hear from you before it's a crisis. A short, friendly message goes a long way:
- Share where to find official county updates and sandbag information.
- Tell them how to report water intrusion, and that you want to hear about it right away, even if it seems small.
- Remind them that their belongings are typically covered by their renters insurance, not your landlord policy, and that flood coverage for contents is a separate question they should ask their agent about.
- Ask them to dump or cover standing water. Officials mentioned mosquito breeding as a concern too.
- Make clear that safety comes first. Nobody should wade through floodwater to move patio furniture.
Then document what you sent and when. If something goes wrong later, you'll be glad you did.
Step three: document the property before the water peaks
Insurance claims go smoother with "before" evidence. If it's safe to do so, get current date-stamped photos or video of:
- The exterior, yard, drainage and the lowest floor level
- The garage, slab edges and any exterior equipment
- Flooring, baseboards and lower walls inside
Coordinate entry with your tenant and give proper notice under your lease and Florida law. A quick, respectful visit beats a surprise one.
Step four: read your insurance, especially the flood part
Standard homeowners and landlord policies generally don't cover rising water. That's flood insurance territory. Pull your policy and confirm what you actually have.
There's a timing wrinkle this year. According to FEMA, the National Flood Insurance Program is authorized only through 11:59 p.m. on December 11, 2026, unless Congress acts. FEMA says that if authorization lapses it would still pay valid claims with available funds, but it would stop selling and renewing policies. New NFIP policies also typically come with a waiting period before coverage starts, so a policy bought during a flood usually won't help with that flood. If your property needs flood coverage, talk with your insurance agent now about NFIP and private options, and about renewal dates that land near December 11.
Step five: know the rules if a unit becomes unlivable
Florida's landlord-tenant law covers this in section 83.63 (casualty damage). In short, if the premises are damaged, other than by the tenant's wrongful or negligent acts, so that the tenant's enjoyment is substantially impaired:
- The tenant may terminate the lease and vacate, or vacate only the unusable part with rent reduced by the fair rental value of that part.
- If the lease is terminated, the landlord must handle the security deposit under section 83.49(3).
- The tenant must get the chance to collect belongings when it's safe, or notice of when they can, within a reasonable time.
Read your lease too, and if you're unsure how it applies to your situation, talk to a Florida landlord-tenant attorney before you make demands either way.
Step six: after the water goes down
- Get the property inspected before anyone treats it as normal again. Flooring, drywall, electrical and AC equipment that sat in water need a professional look.
- Move quickly on drying and mold prevention. In Florida humidity, waiting a week is a decision with consequences.
- Keep every receipt, invoice and photo for your claim.
- Check with the city or county about permits before major repairs.
What about rents and vacancies in Sanford?
For context, Zillow's Sanford rental market page (last updated November 9, 2026) shows an average asking rent of $1,884, up $34 from the prior month and down $116 from a year ago, with 306 rentals available. If you have a vacancy that isn't affected by flooding, keep marketing it normally. If you have one that is, don't list it until it's repaired and inspected. Showing a damp house helps nobody.
Need a hand with a Seminole County rental?
Storms and floods are when a good property manager earns their fee: communicating with tenants, documenting conditions, coordinating vendors and keeping owners informed. If you own in Sanford, Winter Springs, Oviedo, Lake Mary or anywhere else in the county, our Seminole County property management team can help.
Call Bartomeo Property Management at 239-220-0735, visit bartomeo.com, or send us a message. And if you're near the water this week, stay safe first. The paperwork can wait an hour.
Flood forecasts here are from news reporting dated November 9-10 and November 20, 2026, and NWS gauge data from November 20, 2026; check Seminole County Emergency Management and the National Weather Service for current conditions. This is general information, not legal or insurance advice.